The benefit of the current system is that it encourages PCs to spread the chatter. It also makes the chatter more valuable because PCs have to get the chatter from the bartenders when they aren't so busy.
Bartender to Joe Baka, "Sorry, I'm too busy to chat with you right now. Come back later."
Joe Baka to Jane Bata, "That's a drag. What chatter have YOU heard?" or "I guess Bartender isn't going to tell us about the supah sekrit research project that the OTHER bartender told me about yesterday."
It's not like it has been used for deep dark secrets, the content is usually just fun bits and pieces to gossip about. Restricting access in this way just means there will be less of that.
(Edited by Slither at 7:09 am on 12/22/2024)
(Edited by Slither at 7:09 am on 12/22/2024)