Because we are talking about burnout and the IC/OOC bleed on townhall…
This is a share intended to be something some folks can relate to. It's not a knock on staff, who I respect deeply. I present a player view in the hopes it will be heard. It doesn't mean I am upset. If telling this helps one person stay, then that's worth it.
Without ascribing judgment...because I'm sure the staff and players probably are just trying to achieve a positive outcome from their perspective...I will point out that many of these comments, regardless of good intent, sent me into IC/OOC bleedspace and the only thing that really brought me out of it was remembering that I have control over what happens here. With my character, with their reaction.
I've been told the below things IC by staff alts, powerful characters that may have been staff alts, and seen these comments normalized in the playbase (because if the staff alt says it, then it must be okay). Each of them hit me in the OOC feels.
If you encounter these, please know, you are not alone. You are possibly not actually being targeted. But it is/was hurtful to someone else to hear these things too. This may validate your feelings and hopefully give you some reassurance. Breathe and focus on your goals in playing the game. Play on. Speak up respectfully if it's important to you to do so. It's your choice. If you say these things, please note there is potential for unintended impact. Be wise in how and when you say these things.
Why We stay #1: because we can treat an IC guilt trip as just that…IC.
"Your lack of availability is making work less enjoyable for other employees" –> fired from job due to OOC availability. Am I doing something wrong? Ouch.
"You didn't see that" when I definitely did, and the character just didn't know ICly. They figured I was cheating or smallworlding. Dealt with a good amount of grief ICly from this. Let it roll over me.
"It doesn't matter who did that, you shouldn't focus on that" when the who in question is a staff alt. Sure this may be IC protection behavior, but I smell OOC protection of staff and a PC who has been indoctrinated to fear smallworlding. When you hear smallworld is a problem at town hall, you try to do good and protect against it. Even if you don't know for sure that is happening. If a staff member is trying to drive RP and then manipulates others to hide that it came from them, well, that's completely fair game for me to handle ICly.
"You're just going to leave anyway" is a really hard one to hear IC. Yes, I will leave. No, I will not put this fictional game first over real life stuff. You're effectively trying to OOCly guilt me or egg me into being at a disadvantage, either for network or reputation or chyen, because I am leaving. I'm already going to have to deal with that because of absence. Why are you being so rude and making it worse? Not everybody is going to say they look forward to when you get back…but they don't have to add to the guilt.
"You're stagnating" or "why don't you do something" or "you're not looking at this as a challenge" these are all basically just IC phrases to egg people into action. If you don't play a combat character, and combat characters are saying these things to you, guess what you will probably die and lose a lot of stuff. Don't want to go that route? Prepare for people ICly to harass you about not taking the bait. Prepare to be told ICly that you're not respected. Prepare OOCly to hear about it every town hall, how people need to take more risks and not be afraid to lose. My take? The power players in this game are usually combat oriented. There is usually a plan for combat in plots. There is usually a primary path of conflict resolution that requires combat. Conflict is healthy. Conflict is not necessarily combat, but combat is exciting for many. There are limited means to create conflict outside of killing and stealing, but they do exist. You don't have to take the bait and get pulled into combat. Require the people who run these plots to come up with alternative ways of engaging with non-combat oriented PCs. Hold the line. And breathe. It's probably not going to kill you to listen to them rant about your choices not to fight them. And there's probably somebody else new and listening. Survive this instead of getting drawn in, discouraged, and flaming out. You might show them some good survival skills. And you will be the change you want to see.
Why We stay #2: because players can exercise a reasonable amount of control over the outcomes of plots and the future of the City
I get frustrated when I think staff alts get a pass for screwing up the plot or setting up scenarios that make no sense. I'll usually play along to a point, but you can't on the one hand come to town hall and say you want us to find creative ways out of a situation, but then be ICly only accepting solutions that make no sense. Everything said at the 2025 townhall about empowering players to do their own mini plots, or to contribute to the community, falls under this bucket. But gm plots and RP need to be genuinely flexible.
I've had entire allied factions killed off without being ICly allowed to do anything to stop it. Saw the train coming, stepped in to derail it, and found out that the plot points did not allow for me to make the key repairs or deliver warnings. The outcome was pre-set. This one was really hard to stomach and I am still reconciling like years later. I've had to just remind myself that at the faction level, the staff shapes the game and the balance, and what they OOCly have the bandwidth or appetite to focus on. The fact that staff leadership was taking out my faction means no matter what I was going to do, it was going to go away. And that's just kind of how it is. Not worth getting OOCly upset over.
I've also fallen into the perception trap of feeling terrible about getting staff recognition for doing some good RP, when I feel like all I did was go along with their plan and basically not do any real RP or make any decisions except not to fight the flow. When I RP my butt off every day, I get no recognition for it. Have to remind myself it's not a detractor from my other RP…I just can't those kinds of rewards from the PCs I spend all my effort RPing with.
If you are reading this and think hey, I think it's totally fine to say and do these things IC to try and generate RP...then you need to consider it fair game when others use them back at you. I ask myself, is that tit-for-tat really the kind of game I want to be playing? You stabbed me in the feels, so I will go for your feels? Doesn't seem like constructive conflict, or really playing to the theme of the game. But if this is the example others set, then maybe I'm the one playing wrong, if I refrain from doing that?